Endowment policy vs investing it yourself

Many bankers and insurance agents tried to sell me endowment policies. I have never believed in this type of policy. It has got to be the worst payback vehicle ever, i think worse than Singapore savings bonds! They sell it on the basis of fear, what if this you're dead, who will take care of your kids education, blablabla bullshit.

Lets put the numbers to the test, i think it's pretty straightforward. Assuming i'm still around to send my kids to college after 18 years. I've done 2 scenarios based on $200/month and $800/month contributions.

Endowment policy: Guaranteed payback at 2% p.a. It's what they sell you.

Investing it with OCBC BCIP (i'll do a separate post on this): Target interest 4% p.a with dividends, and i still own the shares.

The difference between the 2 plans is astounding! With DIY investing (OCBC BCIP) I'm about $11k ahead based on the $200 scenario, $45k ahead based on the $800 scenario, and I still own the shares and will be paid dividends after the endowment policy timeframe lapses. You can argue that i can purchase shares with the endowment funds after the policy matures, but that defeats the point of dollar cost averaging and dividend investing.

Serious no-brainer, unless you lead a dangerous life living year to year. Most white-collared workers who maintain a healthy lifestyle do not need to invest in endowment policies.

Comments

Trade wars, Hong Kong riots

Be greedy in times of fear. That's the investment mantra I live by. Recently there's been a huge spat on trade wars and the Hong Kong riots, which took a toll on the stock markets. This was a great opportunity to load up on my existing positions as their prices have come down to more favorable levels. There no reason to explore other stocks unless a super attractive opportunity arises, like hongkongland. That counter was hit extremely hard by the riots, since they derive 50% of their revenues from HK. Other than such events where opportunities present itself, I prefer to average up or down into my existing positions... No need to perform the due diligence again, unless fundamentals have changed. I'm enjoying the opportunities that the markets are presenting in the past few months. Simply keep calm and aim to collect more dividends by increasing your stake when frivolous sentiment changes. Market entry is a psychological battle against yourself. Another post on this la

Baby Bonus, Child Development Account (CDA), CPF

"When I'm old and my memory fails me, this post serves as a reminder on what to do." Every child born as a Singapore citizen is given a Child Development Account (CDA), with the government having the intent of cushioning expenses related to raising a child. The CDA funds can be used for certain items like paying for childcare and kindergartens, child related medical expenses, medisave approved integrated shield plans. I use this account for a different purpose, to build my daughters wealth. The only thing that interested me was the Government's Dollar for Dollar match, up to $6k for the 1st and 2nd child. Baby bonus gave us $3k, I topped up $3k , government matched $3k, and the account began with $9k opening balance. Since I can't withdraw these funds for cash, I'll treat this as a CPF account and optimize every dollar. The CPF website has a nice illustration on what happens with the account through time: https://www.areyouready.sg/YourInfoHub/Pag

BCIP 2018 - Singtel, Capitamall trust

I started building my child's college fund when she was 6 months old. All her 红包's are channeled straight into this OCBC account, and I registered for their Blue Chip Investment Plan (BCIP). It's a monthly investment scheme into a blue chip stock of choice. Both Ms EOR and myself contribute monthly to this BCIP account, which is an excellent way to force us to invest. I invest in 2 stocks at any given month, with Singtel being the base investment and the other being a cyclical. Singtel Telco's are considered a defensive sector, with a relatively stable income stream. What I like about Singtel is that they are the market leader in Singapore, and also derive 50% of their profits from investments in other country telcos, thereby reducing the country risk. They are trading at around their 52 week lows in 1H 2018, hence the dividend rate is 5+%, but I see the sustainable rate to be about 4+%. I'm doing dollar cost averaging, so it doesn't matter that much

Eyes On Retirement

Search This Blog