Endowment policy vs investing it yourself Skip to main content

Endowment policy vs investing it yourself

Many bankers and insurance agents tried to sell me endowment policies.  I have never believed in this type of policy. It has got to be the worst payback vehicle ever, i think worse than Singapore savings bonds!  They sell it on the basis of fear, what if this you're dead, who will take care of your kids education, blablabla bullshit.

Lets put the numbers to the test, i think it's pretty straightforward.  Assuming i'm still around to send my kids to college after 18 years.  I've done 2 scenarios based on $200/month and $800/month contributions.

Endowment policy: Guaranteed payback at 2% p.a.  It's what they sell you.


Investing it with OCBC BCIP (i'll do a separate post on this): Target interest 4% p.a with dividends, and i still own the shares.


The difference between the 2 plans is astounding! With DIY investing (OCBC BCIP) I'm about $11k ahead based on the $200 scenario, $45k ahead based on the $800 scenario, and I still own the shares and will be paid dividends after the endowment policy timeframe lapses. You can argue that i can purchase shares with the endowment funds after the policy matures, but that defeats the point of dollar cost averaging and dividend investing.

Serious no-brainer, unless you lead a dangerous life living year to year.  Most white-collared workers who maintain a healthy lifestyle do not need to invest in endowment policies. 
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Trade wars, Hong Kong riots

Be greedy in times of fear. That's the investment mantra I live by. Recently there's been a huge spat on trade wars and the Hong Kong riots, which took a toll on the stock markets.  This was a great opportunity to load up on my existing positions as their prices have come down to more favorable levels. There no reason to explore other stocks unless a super attractive opportunity arises, like hongkongland. That counter was hit extremely hard by the riots, since they derive 50% of their revenues from HK.  Other than such events where opportunities present itself, I prefer to average up or down into my existing positions... No need to perform the due diligence again, unless fundamentals have changed. I'm enjoying the opportunities that the markets are presenting in the past few months.  Simply keep calm and aim to collect more dividends by increasing your stake when frivolous sentiment changes. Market entry is a psychological battle against yourself. Another post on this ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Purchasing life insurance

I recently re-balanced the family's insurance schemes. I remember just when i was just starting out, my cousin once told me to buy only Term + Critical illness insurance. I didn't listen and bought an investment linked plan from one of my friends (he played the friend card, which is annoying). They guarantee you 3% returns or something similar, along with coverage. I bought the Manulink Flexi plan on Nov 1 2008, and had it for 89 months (7years, 5months). Monthly premium was $206.59. Total Premium paid was $18386.51. I remember getting back only around 11k when i surrendered this policy. Basically I paid $7386.51 in total for term + critical insurance coverage for the 7+ years, about 1k per year. Looking back, i did not require such coverage as i didn't have any dependents. Lets see the figures comparing what i would've otherwise gotten, had i invested in a stable dividend stock/reit, since the premise is that this policy is not necessary. I'm looking at a t...
Post a Comment
Read more

I increased term + critical illness coverage further with Manulife

I recently increased my term and critical illness coverage by another $1M and $300k respectively. I checked around with many providers and ended up with Manulife as it's what I need, without all the bells and whistles. AIA offered total coverage for recurrent illnesses, but I figure if I get the same cancer twice, I'd probably be dead by then. So there's no need to pay a premium for that type of policy. Sometimes plain vanilla is the best. I also considered disability insurance where they pay you an amount on a monthly basis. While this sounds like a great idea, the insurers will make it difficult for you to claim this, with strange delay clauses and exclusions. It's much cleaner to receive a large lump sum payment and manage it from there. Why these figures for critical illness? I based it on annual family expenses. Most insurance agents will tell you like 5-10x of your salary, just to get you to buy a bigger policy. An agent that looks out for you will tel...
Post a Comment
Read more